I remember the first time I shopped for pillows. I was moving into my first apartment, and I made the trek to my local Bed, Bath, and Beyond to upgrade from the hand-me-down pillows I used in my dorm.

Sleepers who prefer to sleep on their back need a pillow that has extra support but isn't too tall. Finding the perfect pillow can be a long hunt. There are hundreds of options, with many falling flat ...