I believe Sindhis, and Sindhi culture, gets so much derision, hate, and pilloried is because of its resistance to the state identity in Pakistan. Because Sindh refuses to abandon its roots, Because it is still connected to the 5000 year old history of this region, Because it culturally still connects to the rest of South Asia There is an effort to erase the culture, civilization, and language of Sindh. Just as Bengalis were labelled 'Hindu' or 'Kafirs' in an effort to take over their identity, S